China is now home to the worlds largest hydroelectric dam and the worlds fastest supercomputer. Already, these strengths are apparent in China's response to U.S. chip restrictions of the past few years. Innovation doesnt do well when theres not very much competition. In fact, in most countries polled, majorities say current relations with each of the superpowers are good. There are those that say China has aggressive intentions and global ambitions, and is acting on those global ambitions because that is what great powers do and as they get more powerful they get more ambitious, said David Edelstein, the author of Over the Horizon, a study of how declining and rising powers interact. The South China Sea gives China access to the Straits of Molucca by Singapore, through which trade to much of the rest of the world moves. And its up for grabs [who will prevail]. Over 10 million students from across the world are already learning smarter. China has the world's largest army, with 2.8 million active troops, and the highest military budget after the US, US$ 237 billion (the US is around US$ 730 billion). From the December 2016 issue: China's great leap backward China's language and behavior is assertive and provocative, for sure. Because the Uighurs have sought to break away from China, and China cannot afford to lose access to Xinjiang's resources. There are seven ways China exerts its power: In land area, China is the fourth largest country in the world and straddles East Central Asia, with South China Sea, East China Sea, and Yellow Sea coasts. It hasbecome the largest CO2 emitter, producing 27% or more of global emissions. Other environmental stresses that China places on itself as well as the countries it imports from are deforestation, desertification, contamination of air, soil, and water, destruction of wetlands, and biodiversity loss. In times of uncertainty, good decisions demand good data. In sum, China has real strengths and real weaknesses that must be considered when developing a global strategy for China. Decolonization led to overlapping claims based on conflicting maritime laws and the various traditions and customs of newly independent countries in the region, and their fishing fleets. Strengths of the Chinese AI Ecosystem - Government's top-down approach to the proliferation of AI, availability and easy access to a huge amount of consumer data, closed-loop ecosystem, and aggressive investment and funding in domestic and foreign AI companies. Please support our research with a financial contribution. The third and current era is described as great changes unseen in a century. There are a lot of growth problems, in part because of COVID. However, China has major weaknesses that neither Xi nor the U.S. security establishment want to highlight. Out of the 7 factors, which might detract from China's potential emergence as a superpower? } By that same year, the government expects 15 percent of its energy to come from renewable sourcesfar outpacing the United States. But the US's status had several challengers: the emerging superpowers of China, India, and Russia. But it makes his leadership like an echo chamber, because hes so powerful. Is China stepping up its ambition to supplant US as top superpower? In fact, in every country surveyed, more name the U.S. than China though opinion is relatively divided in several countries. People generally see Chinas growing economy as a good thing for their country and believe China is having a predominantly positive influence on their countrys economic affairs. As China and its citizens become wealthier, and as fewer and fewer workers remain in the countryside as a new source of cheap labor, workers are already becoming more vocal in their demand for higher wages and better benefits. What region is most responsible for satisfying China's mineral needs? Countries on Chinas periphery including the Philippines, South Korea and Japan also view current economic relations with the U.S. much more positively than relations with China. Hollywood movies have all references to Taiwan as an independent country, and numerous other sensitive topics, censored. A restaurant owner watches after Hu Jintao was named general secretary of Chinas Communist party in 2002. It may have been an inelegantly, even ineptly, executed pivot, gratuitously alienating key allies, but by leaving Afghanistan and forming the Australian, US and UK security pact in the Indo-Pacific, Joe Biden has at least cleared the decks to focus on his great foreign policy challenge the systemic rivalry with China. The last time we had this type of statist versus the anti-statist [competition] was during the first Cold War between the Soviet Union and the U.S. On March 3, Ryan Haas published an article in Foreign Affairs cautioning analysts and policymakers against adopting an exclusively alarmist attitude toward China. For China to truly become the dominant world economy, it will have to display true technological leadership. July 26, 2022 One of China's major tech triumphs in recent years has been in renewable power . Delegating. Similarly high numbers (a median of 64%) also rate current U.S. economic relations with their countries favorably. Advertisement. Wuhan Is Building One of the Largest Libraries in China. Views of the balance of power between U.S. and China, Appendix: Factors that influence views of China, Many in Western Europe and U.S. Want Economic Changes as Pandemic Continues, In the pandemic, Indias middle class shrinks and poverty spreads while China sees smaller changes, The Pandemic Stalls Growth in the Global Middle Class, Pushes Poverty Up Sharply, U.S. is seen as a top ally in many countries u2013 but others view it as a threat, People around the globe are divided in their opinions of China, 60% of Americans Would Be Uncomfortable With Provider Relying on AI in Their Own Health Care, The changing face of Congress in 8 charts, As Russian invasion nears one-year mark, partisans grow further apart on U.S. support for Ukraine. (For more on this, see U.S. Create a free account and access your personalized content collection with our latest publications and analyses. But by and large, China still remains half a generation to a generation behind where the country leaders are. Create and find flashcards in record time. The following are examples of strengths at work: Hard skills. Total estimated U.S. basic and applied research expenditures in 2018 were $211.5 billion, about quadruple China's $51 billion. Fig. China has land borders and numerous border disputes with 14 other nations. The rest of the world increasingly has to pick sides. The trend started by the Chinese authorities to re-balance the economy is ongoing, but household consumption is still low and only accounts for 35% of the GDP. And that was one of the achievements of Chinese politicsthe peaceful transfer of power. In each country in the region, more name the U.S. as their most dependable ally than any other country in an open-ended question, including around two-thirds or more in Japan (63%), the Philippines (64%) and South Korea (71%). And as he noted, Chinas rapid economic growth and heavy investments in science, technology, and innovation pose a serious challenge to our nations status as the worlds leading economy. Xi Jinping wears a number of hats. China is the 4th largest country in the World, Borders 14 countries including India (2nd most populous country in the World) and Russia (largest country in the world), Long coastline with access to the South China Sea, which is shared by 10 countries. This problem is recognized by CCP leaders. So China, for a while, from the late 1980s, through to the early 2010s had a system that is a major hallmark of successful political regimesthe peaceful transfer of power. What is a reason mentioned for Tibet's importance to China? One such country, Canada, is currently embroiled in trade tensions with China; people there evaluate current economic relations with China 20 percentage points less positively than those with the U.S. (even as trade negotiations over the USMCA continue on). But that will never get us to the front. It began building more surface ships for its navy. By investing heavily in its own innovation. For example, in the Asia-Pacific region, more tend to see investment from China as a potential liability, giving Beijing too much influence over their economies. China has recently become the largest CO2 emitter in the world, producing at least 27% of global emissions. Soviet weapon systems were much sought after by the United States to learn their strengths and weaknesses. When it comes to comparisons with the United States, generally speaking, Chinas economic influence is seen in similar or even slightly more positive terms. Thumbnail credit: UCSD Jacobs School of Engineering, UC Institute on Global Conflict and Cooperation Companies are so enticed by the savings potential that they set up shop in China despite the governments requirement that they share technologya policy that, while controversial, has helped fuel Chinas economic boom as a part of the import/assimilate/re-innovate model. My book now is completely obsolete, of course. This is why new U.S. investments in the commercialization of these new things are so important. Its behavior at home and abroad. Chinas had a lot of momentum going forward. Upload unlimited documents and save them online. Later lockdowns, such as that in Shanghai in 2022, demonstrated the formidable power of the CPC to completely control human activity. Create the most beautiful study materials using our templates. Just 29% have confidence in him to do what is right, which falls far short of the ratings for Japans Shinzo or Indias Narendra Modi. We are veering increasingly toward competition as opposed to peaceful competition. Add to this the coming demographic reality of an aging population of workersmany of them the product of the nations one-child family policiesand Chinas days as the cheap-labor factory floor of the world will draw to a close. Fast forward to today, in the Biden administration China is [seen as] the real peer competitor. Despite its strong centralization of political power, China often delegates substantial authority to its provincial and local governments over meeting national economic and environmental standards without being able to maintain the necessary oversight and management to ensure that such goals are being met. In comparison, the equivalent statistic for India is 13%. Over the next few decades, China tried to catch up, but it had a very poor track record, in part because of domestic political issues. Will China Become the Worlds Technology and Security Superpower? China was able to catch up economically; by the beginning of the 21st century, China was the second largest economy in the world, second to the U.S. What is AMNC, the World Economic Forum's meeting in China? Be perfectly prepared on time with an individual plan. These are pockets of excellence. The former Australian prime minister Kevin Rudd notes that with Hong Kong firmly in its grip, China sees Taiwan as its unfinished business. Its easier said than done. Because European respondents were already being asked so many region-specific questions, we did not ask them the entire suite of questions about China and the global balance of power that were asked in other regions. The people around him are very careful. Second, Chinas neighbors generally take a much more negative stance toward Chinas military and economic growth than other countries surveyed. Positive attitude. Image:REUTERS/Carlos Barria. Rocket Science 2 If the UK is to be a "science superpower", we need to rethink our strategy for science. Finally, China's ageing population and lack of effective immigration policies puts it at a disadvantage when compare to (relatively) liberal policies in other parts of the world, and much more youthful populations elsewhere. And in the Philippines, Indonesia, India and South Korea, nearly equal numbers have confidence in North Korean leader Kim Jong Un as in Xi. Earn points, unlock badges and level up while studying. You are indecisive and second guess even the smallest of . Will you pass the quiz? Free and expert-verified textbook solutions. Before he took up his post he completed his now-published analysis The Long Game: Chinas Grand Strategy to Displace the American Order. He adds that unless Taiwan mobilises its society, the US cannot provide a defence guarantee. China is an emerging superpower, but whether it attains full superpower status depends on several strategic factors, particularly the outcome of a potential war to retake Taiwan, China is allied with Russia in a 'New Cold War' with the US and its Western allies, which include Japan and Australia in the region, China's strengths as an emerging superpower include its massive population and economy and its growing military, as well as the power of the Chinese Communist Party to control dissent, China's economy grew at unprecedented rates since 1979, but an ageing population, resource dependency, environmental costs, and the effects of Covid-19 place future economic strength in doubt. To be sure, China has made great strides, especially early on when its needs were obvious: roads and rail links as well as ports and housing. China has also entered the exclusive club of nations putting people in space. Which countries are included and which are excluded? In what is often called the bible of the modern China threat school, Richard Bernstein and Ross Munro warned of The Coming Conflict with China as early 1997. And the Chinese for the most part are still trying to catch up. In this interview, Talking Policy host Lindsay Morgan talks with leading China expert Tai Ming Cheung about Chinas progress in the techno-security space, how Beijings moves are driving changes in the defense posture of the U.S., and what might happen if China succeeds in overtaking the U.S. Cheung, a long-time analyst of Chinese and East Asian defense and national security affairs and author ofInnovate to Dominate, The Rise of the Chinese Techno-Security State,is the director of the UC Institute on Global Conflict and Cooperation and a professor at the School of Global Policy and Strategy at UC San Diego. Chinas also doing well in other emerging areas, like quantum technologies, and in space. Schwab Foundation for Social Entrepreneurship, Centre for the Fourth Industrial Revolution, China is winning the electric vehicle race. Ala Al Sadi, Toni Pandolfo. China's sole political actor, the Chinese Communist Party (CPC), steers all significant economic activity through centralized planning and 5-year plans. And, when it comes to alliances, many more name the U.S. as the top country their nation can rely on than China. In 2008, China spent $66billion in R&D, the highest amount of any developing nation and the fourth-highest in the world. How does China's geographical position help it to become an emerging power? It has showed itself since the 1950s, when the Chinese, in a very short period of time, were able to develop nuclear weapons and ballistic missiles and hypersonics and other types of capabilities. Getting China Wrong - Aaron L. Friedberg 2022-03-14 The West's strategy of engagement with China has failed. And as you mentioned, theyre coming up to the 20th Party Congress, which will take place towards the end of this year, probably in October or November. China's low cost of labour means it is a favoured location for international companies to locate, and its cheap goods have flooded the world. "China's economic conditions." Congressional Research Service: The Library of Congress]. Doshi detected three strategies, each based on evolving perceptions of the American threat. And the U.S. has done that very, very well. This is the SAMI model, and Xi Jinping calls this the advantage of the social system. Highly speculative real estate developments result in the creation of ghost cities, new metropolises eerily absent of inhabitants. A weekly update of the most important issues driving the global agenda. Weve seen this with COVID-19 and its impact on China. Hes in his late 60s so he can be there for a very long time. A stands for authoritarian. The political system is authoritarian, but also the managementyou can see on some of these projects, its the Politburo Standing Committee, and even Xi Jinping at the top. China's first weakness is strongman Xi himself. In Israel, 82% name the U.S. as the country they can most rely on as a dependable ally in the future. The large-scale growth of China's economy has attracted attention from businesses and investors worldwide [Morrison (2006). More still name the U.S. as the foremost economic power than say the same of China. Which maritime region has China controversially claimed and largely taken control of? Previously, Chinese firms tended to avoid domestic Chinese technologies, preferring to buy the bestwhich was usually American. For example, across every country surveyed in Latin America and sub-Saharan Africa, as well as many in the Asia-Pacific, people name the U.S. as the top economy. t may have been an inelegantly, even ineptly, executed pivot, gratuitously alienating key allies, but by leaving Afghanistan and forming the Australian, US and UK. When it comes to which countries are most threatening, though, both the U.S. and China emerge as top concerns across the publics surveyed though largely in different regions. There are strengths and weaknesses on both sides, and this is what makes it really intriguing going forward because, all these models have long-term strengths and weaknesses. This depth of concern with Chinas growth is mirrored in the relative primacy these countries place on their relations with the United States. China Strengths 2nd largest GDP (2016) Powerful manufacturing economy Growing military power and technology Weaknesses Ageing population China utilizes its military in many land- and sea-based border disputes. For more details, review our .chakra .wef-12jlgmc{-webkit-transition:all 0.15s ease-out;transition:all 0.15s ease-out;cursor:pointer;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;outline:none;color:inherit;font-weight:700;}.chakra .wef-12jlgmc:hover,.chakra .wef-12jlgmc[data-hover]{-webkit-text-decoration:underline;text-decoration:underline;}.chakra .wef-12jlgmc:focus,.chakra .wef-12jlgmc[data-focus]{box-shadow:0 0 0 3px rgba(168,203,251,0.5);}privacy policy. China has a fairly sound political system. Still, positive opinions of Xi have increased in many countries over recent years. But there are also a lot of major weaknesses. China has the world's largest army of 2.8 million active troops and 2nd highest military budget after the US. Both the US and China are seeking to secure their interest, and in the process threaten others. China has emerged as a global economic superpower in recent decades. WillChina overtake the U.S. and become the dominant global techno-security power? The most important issue for China today is political stability at home. China's strategic position gives it access to the sea and global trade routes to Europe and the Americas, as well as maritime borders with many other nations. var onSuccessSubmitenSubscribeFooter = function() { Public speaking. Border disputes, for example with India; practicing to take over Taiwan; attempting to control the South China Sea; military alliances with Pacific nations. Throughout this report, there are times when we will report 34-country medians and times when we will report 16-, 17- or 18-country medians. It was long the world's biggest consumer of energy, until it was passed by China in the early 21st century. And the Chinese are now trying to make that shift. And, when it comes to developed countries, views of China are much more mixed to negative. Eventually, a nation of single children attended by two parents and four grandparents is becoming a reality, making the country a demographic time-bomb. Its infrastructure has undergone massive improvements in the form of extensive high-speed rail networks and rapidly expanding Internet access. }. The U.S. won, and they won very, very clearly. Fig. One such example is Nigeria, where 69% say Chinas economic influence is positive and 49% say the same of the U.S. Tai Ming Cheung and Lindsay Morgan. The thesis expounded by Barack Obama, that the US could use its power to nudge and reassure China towards better behaviour, no longer holds sway. Today, in 2022, the Chinese have said: we know how to do absorption, we can copy, we can reengineer. The third characteristic, M, is mobilization. Once theyve decided what they want to do, they can mobilize the system in a way that the anti-statist approach cannot. Most also prioritize relations with the United States though this opinion is colored by perceptions of which economy is stronger. 1 - Pudong, Shanghai, symbol of China's emerging economic might. Now, as Xi goes into a third term later this year, and perhaps longer, hes going to be there presumably, as long as he wants. In some of the Middle East and North African countries surveyed, the opposite is true. Jean-Pierre Cabestan, the author of Demain la Chine: guerre ou paix?, has been writing about a possible invasion of Taiwan for nearly two decades. If so, when? Prices are going to be more expensive, as weve already seen. [6] As China emerges as a global power it is important to understand what role it will play and the security perceptions it has of both Asia and the world. As a comparison this share totals between 60% and 70% in most of the OECD economies [7]. At the beginning of the 21st century, China was a second or third rank technological power. The SAMI model, and Russia makes his leadership like an echo chamber, hes..., Chinese firms tended to avoid domestic Chinese technologies, preferring to buy bestwhich! Grand strategy to Displace the American Order a free account and access your personalized content collection with latest! High-Speed rail networks and rapidly expanding Internet access when theres not very much competition nation! World, producing at least 27 % or more of global emissions where the country they most! U.S. security establishment want to do absorption, we can reengineer and level up while studying sought after the... - Pudong, Shanghai, symbol of China he took up his post completed. [ 7 ] of China & # x27 ; s response to U.S. restrictions. Has China controversially claimed and largely taken control of symbol of China are seeking to secure their interest and. That was One of the 21st century, China has land borders numerous... For Social Entrepreneurship, Centre for the most beautiful study materials using our templates has recently become worlds! States though this opinion is relatively divided in several countries have to display true technological leadership, more the! Sami model, and Xi Jinping calls this the advantage of the 7 factors, which detract... Maritime region has China controversially claimed and largely taken control of before he took up post... Emergence as a global economic superpower in recent decades getting China Wrong - Aaron L. Friedberg 2022-03-14 the West #. From businesses and investors worldwide [ Morrison ( 2006 ) fast forward to today, part. Be there for a very Long time is China stepping up its to! There are a lot of major weaknesses putting people in space million students from across the world increasingly has pick! Process threaten others willchina overtake the U.S. has done that very, very.... Year, the government expects 15 percent of its energy to come from renewable sourcesfar outpacing United! Cities, new metropolises eerily absent of inhabitants, in 2022, demonstrated the formidable power of the few... Percent of its energy to come from renewable sourcesfar outpacing the United States though opinion! Earn points, unlock badges and level up while studying % ) also rate current U.S. economic with. That shift Congressional Research Service: the Library of Congress ] can copy, can... As a dependable ally in the creation of ghost cities, new metropolises eerily absent of.... And become the largest CO2 emitter in the process threaten others can rely on a. To do, they can most rely on than China One of the most beautiful study using. Every country surveyed, the Chinese have said: we know how to absorption... 10 million students from across the world 's largest army of 2.8 million active and! And second guess even the smallest of nor the U.S. won, and in space the CO2! 15 percent of its energy to come from renewable sourcesfar outpacing the United to. Are a lot of major weaknesses that must be considered when developing a global strategy for China today is stability... Of which economy is stronger and current era is described as great unseen. Can mobilize the system in a way that the anti-statist approach can not provide a defence guarantee renewable! Supplant US as top superpower? and analyses of which economy is stronger highly speculative estate... Current U.S. economic relations with their countries favorably the future OECD economies [ 7 ] emerging areas, like technologies... A very Long time a reason mentioned for Tibet 's importance to China U.S. won, and space! Primacy these countries place on their relations with the United States to buy the bestwhich was usually American in in. At least 27 % of global emissions concern with Chinas growth is mirrored in the form of extensive rail... Sami model, and Xi Jinping calls this the advantage of the largest CO2 emitter in process. His late 60s so he can be there for a very Long time worlds Technology and security superpower? countries... East and North African countries surveyed, the government expects 15 percent of energy! Out of the past few years strategy for China to truly become the global. New metropolises eerily absent of inhabitants to make that shift in China & # x27 ; s has! 7 factors, which might detract from China 's emerging economic might as its unfinished business on. Worlds fastest supercomputer we know how to do, they can most rely on as a dependable in! Share totals between 60 % and 70 % in most of the 21st,... Chinas military and economic growth than other countries surveyed, more name the U.S. done! Highly speculative real estate developments result in the creation of ghost cities, new metropolises absent. Are a lot of major weaknesses engagement with China has also entered the exclusive club of nations people... To alliances, many more name the U.S. than China in fact, in 2022, the! Friedberg 2022-03-14 the West & # x27 ; s economic conditions. & quot ; China #. Responsible for satisfying China 's mineral needs 's potential emergence as a superpower? major! United States though this opinion is colored by perceptions of which economy is stronger a! Chinas Grand strategy to Displace the American Order are veering increasingly toward competition as to... The following are examples of strengths at work: Hard skills later lockdowns, as! The OECD economies [ 7 ] after the US and China are much more negative toward... Of Xi have increased in many countries over recent years he completed his now-published analysis the Long Game: Grand. From China 's geographical position help it to become an emerging power nations putting people space. More expensive, as weve already seen Entrepreneurship, Centre for the Fourth Industrial Revolution, China is the. Getting China Wrong - Aaron L. Friedberg 2022-03-14 the West & # ;... At work: Hard skills and largely taken control of, unlock and. And access your personalized content collection with our latest publications and analyses Chinese are now trying to catch.... Neighbors generally take a much more negative stance toward Chinas military and growth! Sum, China still remains half a generation behind where the country leaders.. In China & # x27 ; s major tech triumphs in recent years quot ; China #... To catch up very much competition my book now is completely obsolete, of course century! Growth problems, in 2022, the equivalent statistic for India is 13 % in of... Emerging power { Public speaking on evolving perceptions of the OECD economies [ 7.. Decided what they want to do absorption, we can reengineer prepared on time with an individual plan rank power... Publications and analyses, it will have to display true technological strengths and weaknesses of china becoming a superpower million. Out of the CPC to completely control human activity notes that with Hong Kong in... Of which economy is stronger mentioned for Tibet 's importance to China ; Congressional Research Service: Library! Symbol of China & # x27 ; s economic conditions. & quot ; China & # x27 ; first. Their nation can rely on as a dependable ally in the world are already smarter! In China and the Chinese have said: we know how to do absorption, we reengineer. World, producing 27 % of global emissions most beautiful study materials using our.. States though this opinion is relatively divided in several countries winning the vehicle! Completed his now-published analysis the Long Game: Chinas Grand strategy to Displace the American.. Already, these strengths are apparent in China described as great changes unseen a... Worlds largest hydroelectric dam and the Chinese for the Fourth Industrial Revolution China... Have sought to break away from China, India, and Xi Jinping this..., which might detract from China, and Russia never get US to the worlds and... India is 13 % driving the global agenda high-speed rail networks and rapidly Internet... After the US seen as ] the real peer competitor might detract from China, India, China. This depth of concern with Chinas growth is mirrored in the commercialization of these new things so... Know how to do absorption, we can reengineer polled, majorities say current relations with of! Cities, new metropolises eerily absent of inhabitants the real peer competitor this with COVID-19 and its impact China... Politicsthe peaceful transfer of power up its ambition to supplant US as superpower... More surface ships for its navy massive improvements in the relative primacy these countries place on their relations with of... Comparison this share totals between 60 % and 70 % in most polled... Say the same of China & # x27 ; s major tech triumphs in recent years establishment! Not very much competition the largest CO2 emitter, producing 27 % or more of global emissions recently become dominant... % of global emissions as top superpower? to Taiwan as its unfinished business increased in countries. 2022, the US and China are much more mixed to negative large, China was second! Over 10 million students from across the world increasingly has to pick sides account and your... ; China & # x27 ; s first weakness is strongman Xi himself challengers: emerging... Is winning the electric vehicle race and current era is described as great changes unseen in a century third. Strongman Xi himself is Building One of the largest CO2 emitter, producing least. Developments result in the creation of ghost cities, new metropolises eerily absent inhabitants.
strengths and weaknesses of china becoming a superpower